Comments - COVERED BY THE BEATLES VOL.2 - PT.1 - Classic Rock Bottom2024-03-29T00:32:28Zhttps://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profiles/comment/feed?attachedTo=6060463%3ABlogPost%3A36045&xn_auth=noRJ,
For me, it's a tie on Ple…tag:classic-rock-bottom.ning.com,2011-07-16:6060463:Comment:360852011-07-16T16:59:09.266ZMike Pellhttps://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profile/MikePell
<div>RJ,</div>
<div>For me, it's a tie on Please Mr. Postman & You've Really Got A Hold On Me.</div>
<div>But I'll agree, Chuck Berry defeated them on Roll Over Bethoven.</div>
<div>That's funny, you didn't didn't care for either version of Devil In Her Heart, lol!</div>
<div>I didn't either when I was a kid, but now I like the Beatle one.</div>
<div>You should have as much Chuck Berry as possible, he is one of the big three in those early years before Elvis hit, and was the 1st Rock…</div>
<div>RJ,</div>
<div>For me, it's a tie on Please Mr. Postman & You've Really Got A Hold On Me.</div>
<div>But I'll agree, Chuck Berry defeated them on Roll Over Bethoven.</div>
<div>That's funny, you didn't didn't care for either version of Devil In Her Heart, lol!</div>
<div>I didn't either when I was a kid, but now I like the Beatle one.</div>
<div>You should have as much Chuck Berry as possible, he is one of the big three in those early years before Elvis hit, and was the 1st Rock Poet.</div>
<div>The Beatles harmonizing always seemed to fall under the radar- but glad you noticed it.</div>
<div>Thanks for the kind words...and spectacular writing, lol,</div>
<div>Mike</div> Mike,
Alright, we are back to…tag:classic-rock-bottom.ning.com,2011-07-15:6060463:Comment:365102011-07-15T15:43:14.475ZRJhog (Admin)https://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profile/JeffHogland
<p>Mike,</p>
<p>Alright, we are back to current material. Cool. Sorry you've had some issues, hope they get worked out for you real soon.</p>
<p> </p>
<p>On to the show. You played 4 songs by The Beatles and the artists that they covered, and for me, The Beatles went 2-1-1. I'll give them the edge on Please Mr. Postman and You've Really Got A Hold On Me, but Chuck Berry defeated them on Roll Over Bethoven. Now, the tie is from the last tune, Devil In Her Heart, was a draw for me because…</p>
<p>Mike,</p>
<p>Alright, we are back to current material. Cool. Sorry you've had some issues, hope they get worked out for you real soon.</p>
<p> </p>
<p>On to the show. You played 4 songs by The Beatles and the artists that they covered, and for me, The Beatles went 2-1-1. I'll give them the edge on Please Mr. Postman and You've Really Got A Hold On Me, but Chuck Berry defeated them on Roll Over Bethoven. Now, the tie is from the last tune, Devil In Her Heart, was a draw for me because frankly, I didn't care for either version.</p>
<p> </p>
<p>I really have to get me some Chuck Berry. I'll pick up a greatest hits disc one of these days. My favorite song overall for the show is Please Mr. Postman by The Beatles. They did an outstanding job on this. I will say the harmonizing on You've Really Got A Hold On Me is spectacular, just like your show dude!</p> Niels,
So I see we are both B…tag:classic-rock-bottom.ning.com,2011-07-13:6060463:Comment:359672011-07-13T05:02:50.753ZMike Pellhttps://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profile/MikePell
<div>Niels,</div>
<div>So I see we are both Beatlemaniacs, lol!</div>
<div>I frequently play the Beatles on the show, so what a particular show is called may be deceiving.</div>
<div>In fact, I plan to play them next week, as I will finally be revealing my dance, The Mike Pell Shuffle, lol!</div>
<div>Now, as for Please, Mr. Postman, it is a tie for me- I love the way the Marvelettes sing DEE-LIVER DEE LETTER DEE SOONER DEE BETTER!</div>
<div>Hell, I didn't even know the Carpenters did it- need…</div>
<div>Niels,</div>
<div>So I see we are both Beatlemaniacs, lol!</div>
<div>I frequently play the Beatles on the show, so what a particular show is called may be deceiving.</div>
<div>In fact, I plan to play them next week, as I will finally be revealing my dance, The Mike Pell Shuffle, lol!</div>
<div>Now, as for Please, Mr. Postman, it is a tie for me- I love the way the Marvelettes sing DEE-LIVER DEE LETTER DEE SOONER DEE BETTER!</div>
<div>Hell, I didn't even know the Carpenters did it- need some remedial schooling on that group, lol!</div>
<div>After that, I agree Chuck Berry kicks butt on Roll Over Beethoven and easily beats The Beatles.</div>
<div>And I'll go with the Miracles on You Really Got A Hold On Me.</div>
<div>Yes, that one by the Donays is the rare one, Beatles calling it Devil In Her Heart, they calling it Devil In His Heart.</div>
<div>I prefer The Beatles on that one too, but it was fun to hear that obscure original.</div>
<div>Another half coming up, closing With The Beatles, then we move on to an EP.</div>
<div>So I guess, you'll be listening...but dip into those other shows too, as the Fab Four frequently make their way into them.</div>
<div>Thanks for listening and writing your thoughtful picks,</div>
<div>Mike</div> "Please, Mr. Postman" is one…tag:classic-rock-bottom.ning.com,2011-07-12:6060463:Comment:360472011-07-12T12:00:58.062ZNiels (Mod)https://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profile/Niels
<p>"Please, Mr. Postman" is one of my favorite "covered by the Beatles"-songs. Great vocal from Lennon. I did'nt enjoy the Carpenter's version of the song. And when you hear the original version, the Beatles's version is by FAR much better!!</p>
<p>"Roll Over Beethoven" is another story. I don't really like George's vocal on their version. This time the original (a good word for Chuck Berry <img src="http://www.bkserv.net/images/Grin.gif"></img> ) easily beats The Beatles. You can see him do that walk, while you listen to the…</p>
<p>"Please, Mr. Postman" is one of my favorite "covered by the Beatles"-songs. Great vocal from Lennon. I did'nt enjoy the Carpenter's version of the song. And when you hear the original version, the Beatles's version is by FAR much better!!</p>
<p>"Roll Over Beethoven" is another story. I don't really like George's vocal on their version. This time the original (a good word for Chuck Berry <img src="http://www.bkserv.net/images/Grin.gif"/> ) easily beats The Beatles. You can see him do that walk, while you listen to the guitar-solo!! Berry's one of those artist, where you can't really make a better version of his songs.</p>
<p>"You really got a hold on me": Even though Lennon sings great, I prefer the original version. A better production on that one, and better drums, Ringo <img src="http://i925.photobucket.com/albums/ad93/ucsycybersmiley/29.gif"/>!!!</p>
<p>The next one must be the rarity, you wrote about. I can't remember, if I've heard it before. It's an okay song, "Devil in her heart" or what it's called. I prefer The Beatles version this time, because I can't really stand her vocal on the original. It's a bit painfull to listen to <img src="http://i925.photobucket.com/albums/ad93/ucsycybersmiley/107.gif"/></p>
<p>Every time you put on a show "With The Beatles", I'm listening.</p>
<p> </p>
<p> </p>
<p> </p> Okay, Mike. You got me, when…tag:classic-rock-bottom.ning.com,2011-07-12:6060463:Comment:361152011-07-12T08:50:07.252ZNiels (Mod)https://classic-rock-bottom.ning.com/profile/Niels
Okay, Mike. You got me, when it has something to do with the Beatles. I'll listen and comment a little later today.
Okay, Mike. You got me, when it has something to do with the Beatles. I'll listen and comment a little later today.