SMASH OR TRASH - WHERE ARE WE NOW (DAVID BOWIE)

[RJhog (Admin)]

[Scott]

You know you know you know, listening to this was like Walking the Dead!  I have no idea what this is suppose to be about.  So this is where we are with this.  In the TRASH bin.  You know you know you know!

 

So much for the old saying that two heads are better than one!

[Niels (Mod)]

Bowie is kind of the same as Dylan: Their best work were done 40-48 years ago. That's a loooong long time ago.

Not a bad-bad track, but extremely boring.

Good to see he's back, though.

Stash.

[Mike Mills]

The video was weird & creepy. I kept thinking I as looking at a Siamese twin or a freak show attraction & Bowie's head looks really old. The song had Bowie's familiar vocals & it wasn't bad. It was slow & it didn't really have a hook or a Wow factor. Can't see it being a smash, but I've been wrong before. Good to see the old man making music again, I'll go with STASH.

[Jon]

And....it doesn't play.

[Scott]

consider yourself lucky!

[Jon]

I am going to give this SMASH. I really like it. Really mellow and really sad for some reason. Hopefully he does some rawk on the album, but I really can live with this song. Liked the video too, his facial gestures were kind of funny. Now thinking about the song, I'm depressed....

[Michael J. Andrade]

Have to give it a B- for now - but it might grow on me later. Still it won't be on top of the AAA Charts for sure . Lyrics I like but no hook in it ! Bork by the way is the girl in the vid. Why ! I don't know ! Stash !